Constructive Feedback in Slack
SlackEmpathetic ToneTone Shift
Before (Original)
Hey just saw the deck. It's fine but I feel like it could be better in some ways. The slides toward the end felt a bit rushed and some of the data stuff wasn't totally clear. Just something to think about before Thursday.
After (TextGlow Rewrite)Empathetic
Hey, saw the deck — great structure overall. Two things before Thursday: slides 14–16 feel rushed compared to the rest (could use one more sentence of context each), and the chart on slide 18 needs a source cited. Happy to hop on a quick call if it helps.
What Changed
- 1Replaced vague "it could be better" with specific slide numbers and exact issues
- 2Opened with genuine positive framing ("great structure") to make feedback easier to receive
- 3Offered concrete help (a call) instead of leaving the person to figure it out alone
Why Empathetic tone works here
Empathetic tone in peer feedback acknowledges effort before naming problems — making the recipient more likely to act on the notes.
About Empathetic Tone
Prioritizes the reader's emotional experience. Validates before solving. Builds trust in tense situations.
Related Examples
Tone Shift
ManagementDirect
Before
I feel like lately your work hasn't been quite at the level we'd expect. There have been some i...
After
I want to give you direct feedback: the last two deliverables missed deadlines (the API docs by...
Performance Feedback Message
View →Tone Shift
SlackDirect
Before
Hey so I noticed the report still hasn't been updated even though we talked about this last wee...
After
Hey — the report update was due Monday and I don't have it yet. Can you send it by end of day t...
Fixing a Passive-Aggressive Slack DM
View →Quick Fix
ManagementDirect
Before
Hey, so I was thinking it might be good if you could take a look at the vendor situation and ma...
After
Hi Lena, I'd like you to own the vendor evaluation for Q2. Deliverable: a one-page comparison o...
Delegation Message to a Direct Report
View →Want to rewrite like this in 2 clicks?
Install TextGlow — free. Works inside Gmail, Slack, LinkedIn, and everywhere else you write.
Free: 10 rewrites/day · Pro: 150/day for $39/year